My last post, "A Real Estate Show," garnered this response from a friend/colleague, and I thought it opportune to respond here.
Julie. ever since I read this blog post a couple of days ago I've been thinking about it, there's something very disturbing, trying to put my finger on it. I think it is this: the dwellings you picture are dwellings, they are homes to actual people who have joys and sorrows, sicknesses and healths, generosities and greed - they are people like the rest of us, not statistics. I know this, I was in that same area many years ago: they are real people like the rest of us. what did you hope our, the readers, response would be? you offer no entrance here...
R, you’re not the only one who has found this post disturbing. “Depressing” is a word I heard. “Relevant” is another, putting our own [“American”] lives “into perspective.” I wanted to remove the subjective voice (just the facts, ma’am) but that’s a way of being subjective too, isn't it? There are so many stats that I’m still compiling, issues crop up like a Whac-a-Mole and I’m trying to find a way through it myself, it’s a process to be sure.
Let me ask you, would you have felt the same way had I posted luxurious houses, beautiful homes? Would you still need a way to enter?
Statistics do represent real people I post them to communicate a different picture, an overall demographic that is useful for the reader (and me) to understand particular aspects of a country. In this case, it gives concrete numbers to the poverty, health, education, families, women, work, and the environment in Guatemala, and enables me (and the reader) to put these issues into a new context. This morning, for example, I started noticing how many kids I saw in town that weren’t in school. I hadn’t been aware of that before.
The photographs of the homes I took are in stark contrast to traditional travel photos and blogs, the impetus for which was an invitation to participate in recent exhibitions around the Lower East Side based on a 1980 event, the Real Estate Show, staged by Collaborative Projects (Colab), an artist coalition I was involved with back in the late ‘70s/early ‘80s (see below for backstory). Thanks to Lisa Kahane with the help of Coleen Fitzgibben, my work was printed and installed in absentia.
|"'The Real Estate Show' What Next?" at Cuchifritos Gallery + Project Space. Photo: Lisa Kahane|
|Installation view (vertical column to the left of "Free Speech") of Real Estate Guatemala by Julie Harrison, 2014, at Cuchifritos Gallery + Project Space. Photo: Lisa Kahane|
Numerous rounds of e-mails between former members of Colab on the subject of “Frustration with the ‘Art world’ as a means for accomplishing anything” ensued, some debating the reviews garnered (see also below for links), others festering with old wounds and bravado, seeming (to me) endemic of the insular world we occupy in NYC (and the United States).
We forget about the bigger picture sometimes, and living here in Guatemala (or traveling almost anywhere outside the United States, for that matter), helps me understand myself better. I’ve mentioned in this blog the conflicts I have with my “privilege,” whether it’s being educated, light-skinned or middle-class. As an aging hippie, I tend to romanticize the “other” in my travels, and sometimes epitomize a Third-Worldist view, much to my confusion.
When I read other “blogs” about Guatemala, they focus on monuments, history, food, entertainment, culture, recreation, beauty, people, and fun! Good restaurants, cheap or luxury hotels, the expat life! This post was meant as a reality that a lot of people who travel don’t talk about.
I’ve been reflecting on the global refugee crisis, which is probably one of the most troublesome issues to me right now, and how it relates to climate change. There are connections, for example, between the current Syrian war and the preceding years-long drought there that forced so many to become refuges before the war. I shudder to think about what will happen in my children’s lifetime as climate change prevails. But there are so many other problems these days to consider as well, and poverty is a huge one!
Now for the backstory (from the press release): Colab broke into “a vacant city-owned building at 123-125 Delancey St. on December 30,1979 and installed the Real Estate Show on New Year’s Eve, questioning city policies on housing and development. The police closed the exhibition Jan. 2, 1980.
|"Real Estate Show" flyer by Becky Howland, 1979|
|Scene outside the "Real Estate Show" with police guarding city workers nailing the doors shut following the eviction of the artists, 1980. "Octopus Mural" by Becky Howland. Photo: Lawrence Lehmann|
"Negotiations with Colab artists and the City led to the NYC Dept. of Buildings exchanging another city-owned building at 156 Rivington St. to the artists as an alternative to 125 Delancey. Colab artists developed 156 Rivington as the ongoing arts space ABC No Rio, which is still running after 34 years.
|Exterior of ABC No Rio's "Animals Living in Cities" show with dog stencils by Anton Van Dalen,1980. Photo: Anton Van Dalen|
"Meanwhile, 125 Delancey is now a vacant lot waiting to be developed by the Essex Crossing/ Seward Park Urban Renewal (SPURA), which will include a new Warhol Museum. To commemorate this affirmative history between artists, New York City and our new Mayor, there are five galleries presenting exhibitions."
"The Real Estate Show, Was Then… Is Now” exhibition of the original 1980 Real Estate Show artwork; opened Friday April 4th: 6-8 pm James Fuentes Gallery 55 Delancey St (Allen/Eldridge Sts), New York, NY 10002 www.jamesfuentes.com
|Installation view, ‘The Real Estate Show Revisited’ at James Fuentes (image courtesy James Fuentes and the artists), 2014|
“RESx: Real Estate Show Extended” opened Weds. April 9th, 7-10pm, ABC No Rio 156 Rivington St (Suffolk/Clinton Sts), New York, NY 10002. Open call to artists to bring disposable real estate related art through April, including media events. Contact firstname.lastname@example.org for dates & times: www.abcnorio.org
“No City An Island” opened Thurs. April 10, 6-8pm, The Lodge Gallery at 131 Chrystie Street between Delancey and Broome Sts on the Lower East Side. www.thelodgegallery.com
“The Real Estate Show, What Next: 2014” opened Weds. April 18, 5-7pm; Cuchifritos Gallery/Essex St Market 120 Essex St New York, NY 10002; art show and performances. Contact email@example.com for event times, artistsallianceinc.org/cuchifritos-gallery-2/cuchifritos
"In and Around Collaborative Projects" at Spectacle Theater, 124 South 3rd St Brooklyn, NY, 11211, real estate show related film screenings in May 2014; contact firstname.lastname@example.org for dates/times, www.spectacletheater.com
"A Legendary Guerilla Exhibit, 'The Real Estate Show,’ Is Revived in a Proper Gallery" by Daniel Maurer, http://bedfordandbowery.com/2014/04/a-legendary-exhibition-the-real-estate-show-has-been-revived-on-the-les/
"Putting the ‘No’ in ‘Nostalgia’" by Robert C. Morgan, Hyperallergic, April 23, 2014, http://hyperallergic.com/122204/putting-the-no-in-nostalgia/
"A Legendary Guerilla Exhibit, ‘The Real Estate Show,’ Is Revived in a Proper Gallery” by Daniel Maurer, Bedford + Bowery, April 7, 2014, http://bedfordandbowery.com/2014/04/a-legendary-exhibition-the-real-estate-show-has-been-revived-on-the-les/
“'The Real Estate Show' Slideshow and Commentary" by Whitney Kimball, Art Fag City, April 8, 2014, http://artfcity.com/2014/04/08/the-real-estate-show-slideshow-and-commentary/
"The Real Estate Show: Was Then" by Ken Johnson, The New York Times, April 2014, http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/18/arts/design/the-real-estate-show-was-then-1980.html